Best Electric Fireplace Heaters
Top pick: Duraflame DFI-5010 freestanding electric stove
For most rooms, buy the Duraflame DFI-5010 3D Infrared Electric Fireplace Stove. You do not have to install it. It plugs into an ordinary 120 V outlet, and Duraflame rates its heater at 1,500 W. It has an adjustable digital thermostat and shuts itself off if it overheats. The LED flame also runs with the heater off. Walmart lists the black finish (DFI-5010-01) at about $260.
Get Duraflame DFI-5010The ranking uses six points taken from makers’ specifications, owner’s manuals and retail listings: heater wattage and the area the maker claims, whether the flame runs without heat, plug-in 120 V versus hardwired, size and fit, controls and thermostat, and safety listing and price. These picks were not tested. This is what the documentation shows, and it is enough to separate them.
Duraflame lists a 12.5 A draw, five flame brightness levels and a remote control. The same model also comes as DFI-5010-02 (bronze) and DFI-5010-03 (cinnamon), and in cream, navy and French grey. The owner’s manual gives a one-year limited warranty against manufacturing and material defects. It says to keep furniture, pillows, bedding, papers, clothes and curtains at least 3 feet from the front and away from the sides and rear, never to cover the heater, and not to use it outdoors or in bathrooms or laundry areas. It also says children and people with reduced physical, sensory or mental capabilities should not use it unless they are supervised or instructed.
Why it wins: it gives the full 1,500 W that a 120 V plug-in can deliver, and it has a real thermostat instead of just high and low settings. It also costs less than either wall unit here. Who should not buy it: anyone who wants the fire set into a wall or an existing fireplace. Also skip it if you are counting on Duraflame’s 1,000 sq ft figure to heat an open-plan floor by itself. Duraflame labels that figure supplemental zone heating, and 1,500 W does not stretch that far as the only heat source.
The rest, ranked, with who should buy each instead
2. Touchstone Sideline 50 (80004): best wall-recessed unit. Buy it instead of the stove if you want a 50-inch linear fire in the wall. It is 50 3/8 in wide, 21 1/2 in high and 5 1/2 in deep, so it can be recessed into a wall or hang on the wall surface. Touchstone gives a rough opening of 47 1/8 in wide, 20 1/2 in high and 5 3/4 in deep, and recommends placing the unit at least 8 in below the ceiling or a mounted TV and at least 6 in above the floor. Touchstone rates the coil heater with blower at 1,500 W, 5,000 BTU and 400 sq ft. It can be plugged in or hardwired at 120 V, and the flame runs with or without the heater. It has a thermostat with overheat auto-off, a timer from 30 minutes to 7.5 hours, a remote, and a WiFi app that works with Alexa and Google. The warranty covers electronic parts for one year. Retail listings show about $550. The Sideline Elite and Sideline Steel are separate models with their own specifications, and none of these figures apply to them.
Get Touchstone Sideline 503. ClassicFlame 23II042FGL: the cheapest way to fill a small firebox or mantel. Twin-Star, which makes ClassicFlame, no longer lists this insert on its own site. This 23-inch insert is 23.6 in wide, 20 in high and 8.5 in deep, with a box weight of 17.95 lb. ClassicFlame rates its infrared quartz heater at 5,200 BTU, giving supplemental zone heat for up to 1,000 sq ft from a standard 120 V plug. Its Safer Plug monitors the plug’s temperature and cuts power if the plug overheats. Its Safer Sensor turns the heater off if something blocks the front. The timer runs from 30 minutes to 9 hours, and the flame runs without heat. The insert also powers the LED lights on compatible ClassicFlame TV stands and mantels. Retail listings range from about $240 to $350. Choose it over the stove if you already have a mantel or a masonry opening at least 24 in wide. Skip it if the opening is shallower than its 8.5 in depth.
Get ClassicFlame 23II042FGL4. Dimplex XHD26L: the insert to buy when the firebox is 26 in or wider. The Dimplex Multi-Fire XHD 26-inch firebox is 26 in wide, 18 7/8 in high and 7.5 in deep. Dimplex rates its fan-forced heater at 120 V, 1,465 W and 5,000 BTU. The flame works with or without heat. It plugs in and comes with a multi-function remote. Dimplex says to leave clearance for air circulation beneath the unit and at least 1/2 in behind it. Dimplex’s own store lists it at about $495, and other retail listings go up to about $945. Dimplex’s specification sheet gives a 2-year limited warranty on electrical components. Choose it over the 23-inch insert when the opening is at least 24 3/8 in wide, 18 1/2 in high and 8 in deep (Dimplex’s framing dimensions) and a smaller insert would need wide trim around it. Dimplex rates it at 5,000 BTU, against ClassicFlame’s 5,200 BTU.
Get Dimplex XHD26L5. Dimplex Revillusion RBF30: the only pick here rated above 5,200 BTU, on a 208 V or 240 V circuit. This 30-inch built-in firebox is designed to be wired directly to a 120, 208 or 240 V circuit, and an optional plug kit is available. Dimplex’s sell sheet gives these outputs:
Get Dimplex Revillusion RBF30- 120 V: 1,300 W and 4,400 BTU
- 208 V: 1,975 W and 6,745 BTU
- 240 V: 2,575 W and 8,794 BTU
Dimplex says that at 240 V it can be part of a primary heating plan. The heater also runs without the flame. It is 31 1/4 in wide, 26 5/8 in high and 12 1/8 in deep, and Dimplex’s sell sheet lists 67.7 lb. Dimplex’s store lists it at about $1,520 with a two-year limited warranty. Buy it only with an electrician and a 240 V circuit. On a 120 V plug it puts out less heat than the $260 stove.
6. Napoleon NEFL50FH-MT: a wall-hung unit for rooms with glare. The Allure Phantom 50 is 50 in wide, 21 5/8 in high and 5 1/3 in deep (it sticks out about 5 in when hung on the wall), and it hangs on the wall surface without cutting into the wall. Napoleon rates it at 1,500 W and up to 5,000 BTU on 120 V. It can be plugged in or hardwired and needs a 15 A grounded circuit. Napoleon says to plug it directly into a wall outlet, never into an extension cord or power strip, to keep furniture, curtains, bedding and other combustibles at least 36 in from its front, not to install it in a bathroom, to supervise young children in the same room, and to run it only between 41°F and 95°F. The extra money buys a matte surround and a mesh front that cut reflections, plus on-screen controls that dim after 10 seconds. The heat is about the same as the other 1,500 W plug-ins here. A retail listing shows about $1,260 for the 50-inch size. Napoleon’s manual gives a 2-year premium warranty with free replacement electrical components and wearable parts, and labour covered in the first year only. Choose it over the Touchstone only if a window faces the wall and reflections in glass would bother you.
Get Napoleon NEFL50FH-MT7. Real Flame Morris: a TV stand and heater in one piece of furniture. The Morris landscape TV stand is 72 in wide, 18 in deep and 29 in high and weighs 144 lb. It holds TVs up to 70 in and supports 100 lb on top. Its 39 in wide insert runs at 120 V, 1,500 W and 12.6 A for 5,100 BTU from an infrared quartz element. It has five flame brightness levels, six flame colors, a heat-off flame mode, a 6 ft cord with a lay-flat plug, and an anti-topple device. Listings show about $1,540 to $1,630 for the standard version and about $2,250 for the Smart version with Bluetooth control. Buy it only if you need a TV stand anyway. As a heater it matches the stove at several times the price.
Get Real Flame MorrisWhy every 120 V plug-in tops out near 5,100 BTU
Electric resistance heat turns every watt into 3.412 BTU per hour, so a 1,500 W heater makes 5,118 BTU per hour no matter what the box looks like. The figures on this list are the same heater rounded differently: 5,000 from Touchstone and Napoleon, 5,100 from Real Flame, 5,000 from Dimplex, and 5,200 from ClassicFlame. The room-size claims are not the same. Touchstone states 400 sq ft for 1,500 W, while Duraflame, ClassicFlame and Real Flame state 1,000 sq ft for the same wattage. Ignore the square-foot number when you compare.
A common sizing rule for electric heat is about 10 W per square foot. By that rule, 1,500 W covers roughly 150 sq ft as the only heat source in a room with ordinary insulation. In bigger spaces, treat any of these as top-up heat for the room you are sitting in while the central system runs lower. If you only want heat and not a flame, a plain 1,500 W space heater does the same job for less; see the best space heaters for large rooms.
Running cost follows the wattage. On high, 1,500 W uses 1.5 kWh per hour. At 17 cents per kWh that is about 26 cents an hour. The flame alone uses LED lighting and draws a small fraction of that. That is why every pick here can be run for looks in warm months.
Infrared quartz heaters and fan-forced coil heaters give the same heat per watt. Claims that infrared heat keeps natural humidity do not change the physics: warming room air lowers its relative humidity whatever the element. Choose on fit and controls, not on element type.
Getting more than 5,118 BTU takes more than 120 V. The Revillusion reaches 8,794 BTU only on a 240 V circuit, which means an electrician has to hardwire it.
Fitting an insert or a recessed wall unit
Measure an existing firebox twice: at the front opening and again at the back wall, because masonry fireboxes narrow toward the rear. Then measure the depth from the face to the back. The insert’s width, height and depth must all fit within the smallest of those measurements:
- ClassicFlame: 23.6 x 20 x 8.5 in
- Dimplex XHD26L: 26 x 18 7/8 x 7.5 in
- Revillusion: 31 1/4 x 26 5/8 x 12 1/8 in
Power is the step buyers miss. A plug-in insert needs a 120 V outlet, and most masonry fireplaces have none inside. You can either run the cord out of the opening to a wall outlet or have an electrician fit an outlet. Close the chimney damper before installing, because an open flue pulls the insert’s warm air up the chimney. Trim kits cover the gap between a small insert and a larger opening, and one retailer sells the ClassicFlame insert with a trim option.
For a recessed wall unit, the depth of the studs decides. A 2x6 wall has a 5 1/2 in cavity, while Touchstone gives a 5 3/4 in rough-opening depth for the Sideline 50. A 2x4 wall has only 3 1/2 in, so the unit has to be surface-mounted or the wall built out. Check the stud bay for wiring, plumbing and ductwork before cutting. Avoid exterior walls, where recessing the unit means removing insulation. Napoleon’s manual says its unit must not be installed against vapor barrier or exposed insulation, because localized overheating could cause a fire. A surface-mount unit like the 5 in deep Napoleon needs only a bracket screwed into the studs and an outlet within reach of its cord.
Thermostats, timers and safety marks
A thermostat matters more than flame colors. A unit with only high and low settings runs at full output until you switch it off. A thermostat cycles the heater on and off to hold a set temperature, which saves power and stops a small room from overheating. The Duraflame DFI-5010 has an adjustable digital thermostat, and the Touchstone has one too. Timers shut the heater off after a set time: 30 minutes to 7.5 hours on the Touchstone and 30 minutes to 9 hours on the ClassicFlame. They do not replace supervision: Duraflame’s manual says never to leave the heater operating unattended.
Look for a CSA, UL or Intertek ETL mark on the rating plate. UL 1278 is the US safety standard for movable and wall-mounted electric room heaters, and Napoleon’s manual states certification to CSA 22.2 No. 46 / UL 1278. Duraflame, Touchstone, Napoleon and Real Flame state an overheat or automatic safety shutoff. ClassicFlame adds a sensor that watches plug temperature and another that detects a blocked front.
Smart controls are optional. Touchstone builds WiFi plus Alexa and Google voice control into the Sideline 50 with no separate smart model. Real Flame charges about $620 to $710 more for the Smart Morris with Bluetooth. Every pick comes with a remote, so pay for an app only if you want to start the heater before you get home.
What is not worth the money, and where owners go wrong
Not worth paying for:
- A higher square-foot claim, since the wattage is identical.
- An infrared premium.
- A $1,500-plus TV stand bought for its heater, when the firebox inside is a 1,500 W unit like the $260 stove.
Pay more only for something the cheaper unit cannot do: recess into a wall, fill a specific firebox, cut glare, or run on 240 V.
Tripped breakers are the most common problem. At 12.5 to 12.6 A, a 1,500 W heater uses most of a 15 A circuit. Running a vacuum, a space heater or a hair dryer on the same circuit will trip it. Plug the heater straight into a wall outlet, never into a power strip or extension cord; the Duraflame and Napoleon manuals both prohibit them. Replace any outlet that feels hot or holds the plug loosely.
Warranties are short across the whole category. Duraflame and Touchstone give one year, and Dimplex’s store lists two years for the Revillusion. Touchstone’s warranty covers replacing electronic parts that stop working plus phone support, and Touchstone sells one- or two-year extensions on top.
Related guides
- AC and mini split coil-cleaning supplies: mini split cleaning kits and wash bags, no-rinse and foaming evaporator/condenser coil cleaners, fin combs, and soft brushes (by unit type: wall-mounted mini split indoor head, outdoor condenser, window AC)
- AC and mini split condensate management: condensate pumps, drain-line clog prevention and overflow protection
- Best Air Purifiers for Allergies (2026)
- Best Ceiling Fans for Large Rooms (2026)
- Best Electric Baseboard Heaters
FAQ
Can an electric fireplace heat a whole house?
No 120 V plug-in can. A 1,500 W heater makes about 5,118 BTU per hour, which by the common 10 W per square foot rule covers roughly 150 sq ft as the only heat source. Use one as zone heat in the room you are in. The Dimplex Revillusion RBF30 reaches 8,794 BTU on a 240 V circuit, and Dimplex says at that voltage it can be part of a primary heating plan.
Does an electric fireplace need a dedicated circuit?
A 1,500 W unit draws 12.5 to 12.6 A, which is most of a 15 A circuit. If other appliances share the circuit, run the heater on low or expect the breaker to trip. Flame-only mode draws little power.
Can I put an electric insert into my wood-burning fireplace?
Yes, if the insert’s width, height and depth fit the narrowest part of the firebox and a 120 V outlet is within reach of its cord. The ClassicFlame 23II042FGL measures 23.6 x 20 x 8.5 in, and the Dimplex XHD26L measures 26 x 18 7/8 x 7.5 in. Close the damper so warm air does not escape up the chimney, and never burn wood in that fireplace while the insert is in place.
Can the flame run without the heat?
Duraflame, ClassicFlame, Dimplex, Touchstone and Real Flame all state that their flame runs with the heater off, so the fireplace can be used for looks in summer. The LED flame draws far less power than the 1,500 W heater. On the Dimplex Revillusion it also works the other way: the heater runs without the flame.