Lennox vs Carrier: The Best AC and Furnace from Each, and Which to Buy
Lennox and Carrier both sell central air conditioners, furnaces and heat pumps through contractors. What separates them is in the makers’ own figures. Here is the one to buy.
The pick: Lennox SL25KCV
The Lennox SL25KCV is the central air conditioner to buy if you want the most efficient AC either brand makes. It was chosen on four criteria: cooling efficiency, how finely the compressor modulates, sound, and warranty. Lennox rates it at up to 26.0 SEER2, against up to 21 SEER2 for Carrier’s best air conditioner. Its variable-capacity scroll compressor adjusts output in steps as small as 1 percent, Lennox rates it as low as 58 dBA, and Lennox’s warranty covers the compressor for ten years in a home.
On each criterion, the maker’s documents show this:
- Cooling efficiency: Lennox’s product page and specifications handbook list up to 26.0 SEER2 (the short spec table on the same site shows 25.10, and the exact figure depends on the indoor unit it is matched with). Carrier’s top air conditioner, the Infinity 21, is rated up to 21 SEER2.
- Modulation: Lennox’s handbook describes a variable-capacity scroll compressor driven by a DC inverter control that adjusts output “in increments as small as 1%”. The handbook rates cooling operation down to 0°F outdoor air temperature and recommends a freezestat for extra protection during low ambient operation.
- Sound: Lennox’s sound rating is 58 dBA at minimum speed for every size, rising to 68 to 74 dBA at maximum speed depending on size, rated to AHRI Standard 270.
- Warranty: Lennox’s handbook lists a limited ten-year warranty on the compressor and a limited ten-year warranty on all other covered components in residential installations. Lennox’s product page adds a choice for eligible Signature Collection models: a two-year parts extension (12 years of parts coverage in total) or three years of labor coverage alongside the 10 years of parts.
Who should not buy it: anyone who wants to keep their current furnace or air handler, or use a non-Lennox thermostat. Lennox states the SL25KCV can only be matched with Lennox communicating variable-speed furnaces and air handlers, and can only be used with a Lennox communicating thermostat (the S40). Lennox puts it in its top price tier ($$$$ on Lennox’s price guide). In a mild climate with a short cooling season, the Carrier Performance 18 below is the better use of the money.
These picks were not tested; this is what the makers’ specifications, warranty documents and owner reviews show.
These are not boxed products you install yourself. Every unit on this page is installed by a licensed HVAC contractor and matched to an indoor coil and furnace or air handler. Lennox’s SL25KCV handbook warns that improper installation, adjustment, alteration, service or maintenance can cause property damage or personal injury, and that installation and service must be performed by a qualified installer and servicing agency. Neither Lennox nor Carrier publishes an installed price. The installed price depends on the job: the capacity your home needs, the indoor unit it is matched with, the line set, electrical work, duct repairs, permits and local labor. Ask for an itemized written quote.
Buy through the contractor who installs it. Carrier’s limited warranty for its R-454B air conditioners and heat pumps states that it does not cover “any product purchased over the Internet”. Lennox’s basic limited warranty states that no warranty is offered for equipment ordered over the Internet, by telephone or other electronic means unless the seller is also the installing contractor, or a Lennox authorized online reseller sells it to a licensed HVAC installer or contractor. Both warranties also require installation by a licensed HVAC professional. Use the listings to compare models, then have your installer supply the unit.
What you can buy yourself
A furnace, air conditioner or heat pump is put in by an HVAC contractor. These parts around it you can buy yourself on Amazon.
Thermostat. None is offered here. The Lennox SL25KCV picked above works only with Lennox’s own S40 communicating thermostat, which Lennox lists as required and not furnished with the unit, so have the installer put the S40 in the quote.
Filter. Filtrete MPR 1900 filters are MERV 13 1-inch filters made by 3M; Filtrete says to change them at least every 90 days and that they are for residential use only.
Get Filtrete MPR 1900 Air FilterThe room the ducts never reached. For an addition, a finished attic or a garage, there are mini splits sold for homeowner installation; see the one we list and what its maker says to check first.
Air monitor. The Airthings View Plus reads radon, fine particles, carbon dioxide, VOCs, humidity and temperature. Airthings says never to place it outdoors or in conditions with over 85% humidity, which can permanently damage the radon sensor.
Get Airthings View PlusThe Other Picks
Carrier Infinity 21: the Carrier air conditioner to buy
Carrier rates the Carrier Infinity 21 (model 26VNA1) at up to 21 SEER2 and up to 12 EER2, with a variable-speed compressor and Carrier’s Greenspeed Intelligence. Carrier lists its sound level as low as 55 decibels with the Silencer System II and a compressor sound blanket, the lowest “as low as” figure of the flagship air conditioners on this page. It uses Carrier’s WeatherArmor Ultra cabinet and supports up to eight zones. Carrier’s Consumer Choice warranty gives, on timely registration, a choice of a 10-year parts-only limited warranty or 5 years of parts plus 3 years of labor. The warranty period is 5 years if the unit is not registered within 90 days, and the labor option is only offered if the installing dealer takes part in the program. Carrier’s price guide marks it $$$.
Who it suits: a buyer whose best local contractor installs Carrier, who wants the quietest flagship on the makers’ figures, and who will pair it with the Infinity System Control. Carrier’s Ideal Humidity System and InteliSense dealer monitoring are tied to that control. Owner reviews on Carrier’s own page are mostly positive. One owner reports the Infinity 21 is noisier than an earlier Carrier variable-speed unit the same owner bought two years before.
Carrier Performance 18: the value pick for long, hot summers
The Carrier Performance 18 (model 26TPA8) is the one to buy if the flagships cost more than your cooling season will pay back. Carrier rates it at up to 18 SEER2 and up to 14 EER2, with a two-stage compressor and a compressor sound blanket, and as low as 67 decibels. EER2 measures efficiency at a single hot test condition, and here the Performance 18’s 14 EER2 is higher than the Infinity 21’s 12 EER2. For homes that spend many hours at peak heat, that matters as much as the seasonal SEER2 figure. It has the same WeatherArmor Ultra cabinet and the same Consumer Choice warranty as the Infinity 21. Carrier also lists a Coastal version (26TPA8***C). Carrier’s price guide marks it $$, one step below the Infinity line.
Who should buy something else: anyone for whom quiet matters most. At 67 decibels on Carrier’s figure, it is well above the Infinity 21’s 55 and the SL25KCV’s 58. Two-stage operation also removes less humidity than a variable-speed unit that runs long at low output, which Carrier says itself in its air conditioner buying notes.
Lennox EL22KCV: Lennox variable capacity for less
The Lennox EL22KCV is Lennox’s Elite Series variable-capacity air conditioner. Lennox’s spec table rates it at up to 22.50 SEER2 and as low as 60 dB, and Lennox’s price guide marks it $$$, one tier below the SL25KCV. Lennox’s warranty for Elite models is a 10-year limited warranty on the compressor and a 5-year limited warranty on covered components, extended to 10 years with product registration.
Who it suits: a buyer whose contractor installs Lennox and who wants variable-capacity cooling and humidity control without paying for the Signature Collection. Compared with the Carrier Infinity 21, it is the more efficient of the two on the makers’ figures (22.50 against 21 SEER2). The Infinity 21 is the quieter one (55 against 60 dB) and offers a labor option in its standard warranty choice.
Lennox vs Carrier Furnace: Which to Buy
Lennox SLP99V: the furnace to buy
The Lennox SLP99V is the gas furnace to buy, and the one to pair with the SL25KCV. Lennox rates it at up to 99% AFUE, with modulating heat, a variable-speed blower, SilentComfort technology and a fully insulated cabinet. Lennox’s basic limited warranty covers its heat exchanger for a limited lifetime for the original owner in a home (20 years for later owners) and other covered components for ten years. Its product page offers the same choice for eligible Signature Collection models as the SL25KCV: 12 years of parts coverage in total, or 10 years of parts plus 3 years of labor. Lennox’s price guide marks it $$$$.
Carrier Infinity 98: the Carrier furnace to buy
The Carrier Infinity 98 (model 59MN7) is the furnace to buy if your system is Carrier. Carrier rates it at up to 98.5% AFUE, with a modulating gas valve that, paired with the Infinity System Control, adjusts in 1% increments, plus a variable-speed blower and a fully insulated cabinet. Carrier gives it a lifetime heat exchanger limited warranty on registration within 90 days (20 years if not registered), and the same 10-year parts or 5-year parts plus 3-year labor choice as its air conditioners.
On efficiency the two are half a point of AFUE apart, which will not show on a gas bill. The real difference is the paperwork: Lennox’s basic warranty gives the SLP99V’s lifetime heat exchanger term to the original owner without a registration condition in the warranty text. Carrier’s lifetime term depends on registering within 90 days. Carrier also states that the Infinity 98 does not meet the 14 ng/J NOx limit in SCAQMD Rule 1111 or SJVAPCD Rule 4905, so it cannot be installed in the South Coast or San Joaquin Valley air districts in California.
Lennox SL297NV: for California’s ultra-low-NOx districts
For homes in those California districts, the Lennox SL297NV is the furnace to look at. Lennox calls it an ultra-low emissions gas furnace, rates it at up to 97.5% AFUE on its product page, and lists it as available in select parts of California. Lennox states that one SL297NV size (SL297UH040NV36B) was among the first fan-type central furnaces to meet the 14 ng/J NOx limit. Its heat exchanger has the same limited lifetime term for the original owner in Lennox’s basic warranty as the SLP99V.
Readers often ask about the Lennox SL280NV. Lennox lists it as an ultra-low emissions furnace rated up to 80% AFUE, also for select parts of California. It is not a high-efficiency condensing furnace. Outside California, Lennox points buyers to the SL280V instead.
Lennox vs Carrier Heat Pump
Carrier Infinity 21 Cold Climate Heat Pump: the heat pump to buy
The Carrier Infinity 21 Cold Climate Heat Pump (model 27VNA1) beats Lennox’s best cold-climate heat pump on heating efficiency, and that is the reason to pick it. Carrier rates it at up to 21.2 SEER2, 13.5 EER2 and 12.5 HSPF2, with a variable-speed compressor that runs between 30% and 100% capacity. Carrier states heating operation down to -23°F and lists it as low as 54 decibels. Carrier offers it in one size that modulates up and down, so the contractor’s load calculation decides whether it fits your home.
Lennox SL22KLV: the Lennox alternative
The Lennox SL22KLV cold climate heat pump is rated by Lennox at up to 21.10 SEER2, 13.2 EER2 and 10.50 HSPF2, as low as 58 dB, with heating down to -20°F. Lennox’s price guide marks it $$$$. Buy it if your system is Lennox or if the single Carrier size does not fit your home’s load. If you are still deciding between a heat pump and a gas furnace, see heat pump vs furnace.
Quick Comparison
| Category | Lennox | Carrier |
|---|---|---|
| Top air conditioner | SL25KCV: up to 26.0 SEER2, as low as 58 dBA | Infinity 21: up to 21 SEER2, 12 EER2, as low as 55 dB |
| Mid-tier air conditioner | EL22KCV: up to 22.50 SEER2, as low as 60 dB | Performance 18: up to 18 SEER2, 14 EER2, as low as 67 dB |
| Top gas furnace | SLP99V: up to 99% AFUE, modulating | Infinity 98: up to 98.5% AFUE, modulating |
| Cold-climate heat pump | SL22KLV: 21.10 SEER2, 10.50 HSPF2, to -20°F | Infinity 21 Cold Climate: 21.2 SEER2, 12.5 HSPF2, to -23°F |
| Parts warranty | 10 years (Signature); choice of 12 years parts, or 10 years parts plus 3 years labor | 10 years parts on registration within 90 days, or 5 years parts plus 3 years labor |
| Thermostat | Lennox S40 required for the SL25KCV | Infinity System Control for Infinity features |
The two makers’ price guides use different scales: Lennox runs from $ to $$$$, Carrier’s air conditioner guide from $ to $$$. Do not compare symbols across brands; compare written quotes.
Where the XC25 and Infinity 26 Went
Lennox no longer lists the XC25 among its current air conditioners. Its current flagship is the SL25KCV, which uses R-454B refrigerant. Lennox lists R-454B as lower flammability (A2L) and requires a refrigerant detection system on the indoor unit of every R-454B system. Carrier’s current air conditioner line tops out at the Infinity 21; an Infinity 26 air conditioner is no longer on its list. If a contractor quotes either older model, ask whether it is leftover stock and which refrigerant it uses, because parts and refrigerant for the older systems differ from the current R-454B line.
How to Choose Between Lennox and Carrier
The spec sheet rarely decides this on its own. Both brands sell variable-capacity systems, both reach the high 90s in furnace AFUE, and both offer ten-year parts coverage. What separates them in practice is how your house, your climate and the contractor available to you fit each brand’s design.
Start with the installer, not the model. A variable-speed air conditioner or heat pump depends on correct refrigerant charge, line set sizing and airflow. Lennox’s own handbook for the SL25KCV notes that its variable-speed compressor needs extra care in refrigerant piping sizing. A poorly commissioned inverter system can run noisier or short-cycle, whatever its SEER2. If the only well-reviewed dealer near you sells one brand, that usually outweighs a few points of SEER2 from the other.
Match the system to your ductwork. Variable-speed equipment moves less air at a time, for longer. Leaky, undersized or restricted ducts can erase much of the comfort and efficiency benefit. If your ducts are in poor shape, budget for sealing or repair before paying for a top-tier outdoor unit.
Size it with a load calculation. Ask for a Manual J load calculation rather than a size copied from the old unit. Carrier’s own buying notes warn that an oversized unit short-cycles and handles humidity poorly. That is a bigger comfort problem than the gap between these two brands, and the HVAC sizing calculator gives a starting point.
What Spending More Actually Buys
Moving up a tier within either brand buys finer compressor modulation, lower sound and better humidity control. Single-stage units cycle fully on or off. Two-stage units add a lower running speed. Variable-capacity units adjust output continuously, which holds temperature steadier and removes moisture more evenly because the system runs longer at low output. Carrier says the same about its own line: variable-speed systems run at lower speeds for longer and pull more humidity than two-stage or single-stage ones.
What the upgrade does not buy is a guaranteed lower bill. Savings from a higher SEER2 depend on how many hours you cool, your electricity rate and your duct losses. In a mild climate with a short cooling season, a mid-tier system often pays back its extra cost slowly. In a hot, humid region with long runtimes, the low-speed operation of a variable-capacity unit is more likely to justify the premium.
The other cost to weigh is the controls. Both brands’ top systems depend on their own communicating thermostats: Lennox requires a Lennox communicating thermostat for the SL25KCV, and Carrier describes its Infinity System Control as designed exclusively for Infinity products. If that thermostat or an outdoor control board fails out of warranty, the replacement comes from that brand. For third-party options on standard equipment, see the best smart thermostats.
Warranty: What the Paper Says
Both makers’ warranties cover parts, not the labor to fit them, unless you take the labor option. Carrier’s warranty excludes labor for diagnosing, repairing or replacing parts, and the cost of refrigerant. Lennox’s basic limited warranty says the owner pays trip charges, labor and diagnostic costs, and that claims must be filed within 45 days of the failure. Carrier’s labor option (5 years parts plus 3 years labor) is only available if your installing dealer has joined Carrier’s Consumer Choice program. Lennox’s equivalent labor choice applies to eligible Signature Collection models.
Where you buy the unit matters as much as which one you buy. Carrier’s condensing-unit warranty excludes any product purchased over the Internet. Lennox’s excludes equipment ordered online or by phone unless the seller is also the installing contractor, or is a Lennox authorized online reseller selling to a licensed HVAC contractor.
Registration matters more on Carrier. Carrier’s parts warranty drops to 5 years, and the Infinity 98’s heat exchanger term to 20 years, if the equipment is not registered within 90 days. Make registration part of the installer’s written scope, and get the installer’s own labor warranty in writing too.
Dealer Network and Service
Lennox sells through independent Lennox dealers. Its basic warranty says that if a covered component is no longer available, replacement equipment Lennox offers at a reduced price must be bought through and installed by an independent Lennox dealer. Carrier sells through its own dealer network. How many dealers of each brand work near you varies by area, and that local count decides how much competition you get on price and scheduling. Get quotes from at least two dealers for the same capacity and equipment tier.
Mini Splits
This page covers ducted systems. Both brands sell ductless lines, but if a mini split is the priority, compare the brands that focus on them: see Daikin vs Mitsubishi mini splits and the best mini split AC systems. If you are already working with a Lennox or Carrier dealer and want one warranty relationship for the whole house, ask that dealer which ductless models they install.
Common Problems to Plan For
- Warranty registration: Carrier’s 10-year parts term and the Infinity 98’s lifetime heat exchanger term both depend on registration within 90 days.
- Labor is separate: Manufacturer warranties cover parts; ask the installer what their labor warranty covers and for how long.
- Mismatched components: The SL25KCV only works with Lennox communicating variable-speed indoor units. Pairing any new outdoor unit with an old indoor coil or furnace can cost efficiency, cause refrigerant compatibility trouble, or void a warranty. Ask whether the quote includes the matched coil and furnace or air handler.
- Coastal sites: Salt air speeds coil corrosion. Carrier lists a Coastal version of the Performance 18, and regular coil cleaning matters more here than the brand badge.
- Maintenance: Annual service, clean filters and a clear condensate drain prevent most avoidable breakdowns on either brand.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Lennox more reliable than Carrier?
Neither maker publishes failure rates, so no document settles it. What decides reliability in practice is installation quality and maintenance. Choose on the quality of the dealer in your area, then on the figures above.
Which brand is more energy efficient?
On the makers’ figures, Lennox for air conditioning and furnaces, Carrier for heat pump heating. The Lennox SL25KCV is rated up to 26.0 SEER2 against 21 SEER2 for the Carrier Infinity 21, and the Lennox SLP99V up to 99% AFUE against 98.5% for the Carrier Infinity 98. The Carrier Infinity 21 Cold Climate Heat Pump is rated 12.5 HSPF2 against 10.50 for the Lennox SL22KLV.
Can I use a third-party thermostat with Lennox or Carrier?
Not with the Lennox SL25KCV: Lennox states it can only be used with a Lennox communicating thermostat. Carrier pairs the Infinity 21 with its Infinity System Control, and the Ideal Humidity System and InteliSense features depend on it. The Carrier Performance 18 is shown with the ecobee for Carrier smart thermostat.
Which brand has cheaper repairs?
Neither maker publishes repair part prices. What drives repair cost is labor and whether the failed part is proprietary. Both brands’ top systems use proprietary communicating controls, and both warranties cover parts only unless you take the labor option.
How long do Lennox and Carrier systems last?
Carrier states that air conditioners typically last 15 to 20 years with proper maintenance. Usage, climate, installation quality and regular upkeep decide where in that range a system lands.
Which should I choose: Lennox or Carrier?
For the most efficient air conditioner, the Lennox SL25KCV. For the quietest flagship on the makers’ figures and a labor option in the warranty choice, the Carrier Infinity 21. For value in a hot climate, the Carrier Performance 18. For a furnace, the Lennox SLP99V, or the Carrier Infinity 98 if your system is Carrier. For a cold-climate heat pump, the Carrier Infinity 21 Cold Climate Heat Pump. If the best dealer near you sells only one of the two brands, buy that brand’s pick.
Related Articles
- Carrier vs Trane vs Lennox: three-way brand comparison
- Trane vs Lennox: another major brand comparison
- Rheem vs Carrier: mid-range vs premium brand comparison
- Goodman vs Lennox: value leader vs Lennox
- Best Central Air Conditioners: central AC picks across all brands
- Best Gas Furnaces: furnace picks across all brands
- HVAC Buying Guide: choosing your next system